Accountability

Background

Compliance Advisor Ombudsman (CAO) and dispute resolution process

11 April 2014

Meg Taylor, CAO

  • We have recently reviewed our operational guidelines and wanted to introduce more how dispute resolution works

Gina Barbieri, CAO

  • Overview of the CAO’s processes including assessment process; our work must be on social/environmental harm; and linked to impacted people
  • Three roles: dispute resolution, compliance, advisor
  • Overview of the dispute resolution process, we let communities decide if the settlement is fair
  • Principles on dispute resolution: voluntary, neutral, equitable treatment, confidentiality AND transparency

Scott Adams, CAO

  • Role of NGO in the process – can help with many things
  • Positive context for dispute resolution: issues negotiable, time, relationships, capacity, etc
  • Need to think about the legal framework and legal proceedings
  • Challenges: agreement is just the beginning, implementation issues

Case study – New Forest Company, Uganda

  • Agreement reached on resettlement etc; large plot of land now purchased for a community cooperative society
  • Organic development of relationship between the company and the community
  • Government officials asked about lessons learned, and realised that they need to do things differently

Meg Taylor, CAO

  • We can be frustrated by a lack of heart at the institutions
  • The cases we are getting now are very complex, and land competition is very tough to work with – there are not places for resettlement
  • What is the role of the institution? Can the IFC have a fund for restitution? What about a fund for community development?

Discussion

Q: issues of sequencing, why not start compliance sooner?

Q: anything done on an ICSID case?

Meg Taylor – we want to get results for the community so don’t want to do compliance at the beginning, learning lessons for IFC is secondary to community outcomes

Scott – nothing on ICSID yet

Q: the major problem is corruption; also are you using the evaluation department? Who nominates a panel for compliance?

Q: average timeframes of resolution?

Gina – usually at least 6 months, average 2 years

Q: mechanisms for funding community development?

Meg – we haven’t fully thought this through yet.

Gina – IFC has talked about getting clients to pay up front for this, but there are not mechanisms yet and IFC has expressed willingness

More background on this issue

Rights

Background

20 November 2015 | Minutes

UK civil society meeting with Minister of State Desmond Swayne

Notes from a meeting on 7 September 2015 between the Minister of State of the UK Department for International Development (DFID) and civil society representatives, focusing on the World Bank's safeguards review.

IFI governance

Background

10 October 2014 | Minutes

UK civil society meeting with UK World Bank Executive Director Gwen Hines

Notes of a meeting with World Bank executive director Gwen Hines in October 2014.

IFI governance

Background

12 April 2014

An overview of the World Bank Group's new country engagement model

Trade

Background

11 April 2014 | Minutes

The future of Doing Business

IFI governance

Background

11 April 2014

What does real accountability mean in practice?

Accountability

Background

11 April 2014

Compliance Advisor Ombudsman (CAO) and dispute resolution process

IFI governance

Background

10 April 2014 | Minutes

CSOs - Inspection Panel meeting and discussion

Rights

Background

10 April 2014 | Minutes

Smart assessment: Capturing and managing human rights risks

IFI governance

Background

9 April 2014

IFC – Dinant and lessons learned

IFI governance

Background

8 April 2014

CSO roundtable with World Bank Group executive directors

Rights

Background

7 April 2014

Multilateral Development Banks & human rights: Issues, challenges, opportunities

Rights

Background

17 May 2013 | Minutes

Notes of IFC-CSO discussion of CAO financial markets audit

IFC has responsed to a letter from a number of NGOs sent to President Kim. These notes are from a 19 April 2013 meeting at IFC headquarters in Washington DC.

UK

Background

9 October 2008 | Minutes

Highlights: Meeting of UK NGOs with UK Alternate Executive Director to the World Bank

Meeting between UK NGOs and UK Alternate Execituve Director to the World Bank Caroline Sergeant on 5 September 2008.

IFI governance

Background

30 September 2008 | Minutes

UK NGO meeting with the Secretary of State for International Development, on the World Bank

Summary of meeting: the main agenda items were (1) World Bank governance; and (2) Climate change.

Latest articles on this issue

Rights

News

Calls for the World Bank to suspend funding to Honduras amid continued human rights concerns

Civil society responds to World Bank president Jim Yong Kim statement on human rights abuses and displacement by calls for the World Bank to suspend funding to Honduras amid continued human rights concerns.

29 June 2016

IFI governance

News

World Bank’s risk rating record for policy lending slammed by internal evaluator

A report by the World Bank’s Independent Evaluation Group has criticised the Bank’s track record in rating the risks of development policy loans.

9 February 2016

Rights

News

Renewed warnings over World Bank safeguards “dilution”

Further concerns have been raised over dilutions of the World Bank’s proposed new safeguards framework, as controversy arose over a Bank waiver of the indigenous peoples policy for a Tanzania project.

29 June 2016

Finance

Analysis

What is left of the rise of the South?

While the recent reforms to the IMF and World Bank governance reforms and the establishment of new Southern-led IFIs are symbolically important, they are thus far not a rupture with the Western-dominated international financial architecture.

5 April 2016 | Guest analysis
Graffiti remembrance of Berta Cáceres in London

Private Sector

News

IFC investments through financial intermediaries linked to human rights abuses in Honduras, again

A new complaint was lodged with the CAO regarding an IFC financial intermediary investment in Honduras, while another financial intermediary case, previously linked to the IFC, escalate into violence.

5 April 2016

Infrastructure

Commentary

Powerless: a call for World Bank community engagement in Nepal

Following a longstanding conflict over a World Bank-funded power line in Nepal, communities call for a fair dispute resolution process and meaningful consultation.

5 April 2016 | Comment

IFI governance

Analysis

IFC claims “absolute immunity” to avoid justice. But will it hold up in court?

This briefing provides an overview of the immunity of international organisations in US law, looking at a lawsuit brought against the IFC regarding the Tata Mundra coal power plant in India.

5 April 2016 | At Issue

IFI governance

Analysis

Where’s the remedy? Development banks must do more to remedy harm caused by the activities they finance

A report assessing the effectiveness of 11 development bank’s accountability systems found that they are not effective at consistently providing remedy to those harmed.

10 February 2016 | Guest analysis

Rights

Background

UK civil society meeting with Minister of State Desmond Swayne

Notes from a meeting on 7 September 2015 between the Minister of State of the UK Department for International Development (DFID) and civil society representatives, focusing on the World Bank's safeguards review.

20 November 2015 | Minutes

Accountability

News

IMF updates CSO guidelines

In mid-September the IMF concluded a consultation on its 2015 guidelines on the IMF staff engagement with civil society organisations.

28 September 2015